New Sticky Note

NOTICE: This league is using the BLEEDING EDGE game engine. For more information, click here.

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

League Forums

Main - General MFN Discussion

Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By raidergreg69
5/26/2023 1:18 am
My team in MFN 74 https://mfn74.myfootballnow.com/team/2 had an in game kicker injury and it resulted in a WR kicking FGs. Now that WR was 2 for 2 but I find it curious the AI took the regular kicker out for a hand injury.

Also begs the question of what to do next game, as he is currently listed as Out for 3 weeks. I'll probably need a kicker for at least 1 week anyway as I don't want to risk having him active and having AI put my WR back in as kicker because of a 0% hand.

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By Mcbolt55
5/26/2023 1:39 am
That’s a new one, crazy ridiculous.

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By raidergreg69
5/26/2023 11:55 am
I think this is the first time I've seen a kicker injured

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By jlyman
5/26/2023 9:18 pm
Injured making a tackle on a kickoff. Looks like he needs a remedial course in proper tackling technique. Maybe McAfee could give him some pointers...? :)

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By Mcbolt55
5/26/2023 9:21 pm
Along that thread, I wonder why punters can’t have good kick off skills…that way the punter could/should handle any defensive duties, the kicker would still be ok for field goals…

I understand why the punter can’t kick fg and kicker can’t punt to force having both on a roster…but either one should be able to handle kickoffs
Last edited at 5/26/2023 9:23 pm

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By Cjfred68
5/28/2023 4:25 pm
Mcbolt55 wrote:
Along that thread, I wonder why punters can’t have good kick off skills…that way the punter could/should handle any defensive duties, the kicker would still be ok for field goals…

I understand why the punter can’t kick fg and kicker can’t punt to force having both on a roster…but either one should be able to handle kickoffs


I kinda agree with this: both kickers should have remedial attributes at the opposite position....not great but better then a WR or other non-kicker.

There have been a few QBs over the years that were decent punters with Danny White the best!!!

I think Flutie kicked and punted if I'm remembering right...Greg probably knows

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By Mcbolt55
5/28/2023 4:34 pm
For years the patriots kept Tupa around as the punter, but also the backup qb (usually the 3rd option, but there were seasons where he was #2 and there was no other backup). The wr welker kicked for the dolphins b4 his patriot days in emergency situations and I know multiple other qbs and position players have been involved, especially before the modern kicking specialists took over, but that is ancient history. But then again, the way everybody treated the 4.6 update, we are playing the old school game now more than this century’s version of the game.
Last edited at 5/28/2023 4:35 pm

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By Cjfred68
5/28/2023 5:55 pm
Mcbolt55 wrote:
But then again, the way everybody treated the 4.6 update, we are playing the old school game now more than this century’s version of the game.


That was a year ago before we cracked the 4.6 code and starting throwing the ball for 5,000+ yards a season. There is always a way but it takes time to hone in on it.

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By raidergreg69
5/28/2023 9:50 pm
Cjfred68 wrote:
Mcbolt55 wrote:
Along that thread, I wonder why punters can’t have good kick off skills…that way the punter could/should handle any defensive duties, the kicker would still be ok for field goals…

I understand why the punter can’t kick fg and kicker can’t punt to force having both on a roster…but either one should be able to handle kickoffs


I kinda agree with this: both kickers should have remedial attributes at the opposite position....not great but better then a WR or other non-kicker.

There have been a few QBs over the years that were decent punters with Danny White the best!!!

I think Flutie kicked and punted if I'm remembering right...Greg probably knows


Idk about a regular punter but I believe Flutie is the last player to perform a successful dropkick in a game

Re: Kicker Injures Hand, Can't Kick

By Mcbolt55
5/28/2023 10:24 pm
Cjfred68 wrote:

That was a year ago before we cracked the 4.6 code and starting throwing the ball for 5,000+ yards a season. There is always a way but it takes time to hone in on it.


By playing 190lb TE’s and LBs and using the same 12 passing/def plays that always worked, but that is a grievance for a different thread. I do it too, just to survive.