New Sticky Note

NOTICE: This league is using the BLEEDING EDGE game engine. For more information, click here.

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

League Forums

Main - Bug Box

Re: Safety Not Given

By Gustoon
5/15/2015 9:26 am
I saw this in another thread (can't find it, sorry). Now it appears that we were robbed of a safety and possibly the game.

1-10-MKE 1 (1:44) 22-Charles Foxworth ran for -3 yards. Tackle by 54-Wallace Hall. SAFETY! (54-Wallace Hall) PENALTY - Holding (MKE 87-Lewis Hartley) (Declined)1-13-MKE 1 (1:44) 22-Charles Foxworth ran for -3 yards. Tackle by 54-Wallace Hall. SAFETY! (54-Wallace Hall) PENALTY - Holding (MKE 87-Lewis Hartley)
Offensive Play: Singleback Big Off Tackle Strong
Defensive Play: 4-3 Normal Double WR2


Very next series they march down field and we hold them to 3 making it 10 - 0. Had we got the safety and possession, this game would have been a lot different.
The play - http://cust10.myfootballnow.com/watch/590#109789

Our division is really tight and needed this to keep in touch, now its an almost impossible task.
This has really pissed me off, it makes me wonder what else got called wrong.
Last edited at 5/15/2015 9:26 am

Re: Safety Not Given

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
5/15/2015 12:48 pm
Obviously this is an issue with the 0.3 release where safeties are a bit wacky. I'm putting a patch in that will hopefully fix this for future games - please continue to report any odd safety issues.

Re: Safety Not Given

By Sardean
5/16/2015 8:26 am
JDB its not a problem, clearly the player actually made it out of the end zone, can you not see? tsk tsk tsk

Re: Safety Not Given

By Pittball1
5/23/2015 8:16 pm
reading the play call the penalty was declined then it looks like it went through the play again and the penalty wasn't declined so it gave the ball back to the offense

Re: Safety Not Given

By Gustoon
5/24/2015 2:08 am
Pittball1 wrote:
reading the play call the penalty was declined then it looks like it went through the play again and the penalty wasn't declined so it gave the ball back to the offense

No its all the same play....

I'll break it down....
1-10-MKE 1 (1:44) 22-Charles Foxworth ran for -3 yards. Tackle by 54-Wallace Hall. SAFETY! (54-Wallace Hall)
This was the play.

PENALTY - Holding (MKE 87-Lewis Hartley) (Declined)1-13-MKE 1 (1:44) 22-Charles Foxworth ran for -3 yards. Tackle by 54-Wallace Hall. SAFETY! (54-Wallace Hall) PENALTY - Holding (MKE 87-Lewis Hartley)
This was the summary
The 'Hold' penalty was declined in favor of the safety, but, (and I don't know if this is what you mean) in negating the hold penalty, the original play was run again, eg: 1st and 10 , which ever way its a bug.

Re: Safety Not Given

By Sardean
5/24/2015 2:17 am
safety first i always say. if it's not on it's not on.

Re: Safety Not Given

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
5/24/2015 9:39 am
I did identify this bug and it should be fixed. Let me know if you see it in a future game.
Last edited at 5/24/2015 9:40 am

Re: Safety Not Given

By Pittball1
5/24/2015 1:26 pm
Gustoon wrote:
Pittball1 wrote:
reading the play call the penalty was declined then it looks like it went through the play again and the penalty wasn't declined so it gave the ball back to the offense

No its all the same play....

I'll break it down....
1-10-MKE 1 (1:44) 22-Charles Foxworth ran for -3 yards. Tackle by 54-Wallace Hall. SAFETY! (54-Wallace Hall)
This was the play.

PENALTY - Holding (MKE 87-Lewis Hartley) (Declined)1-13-MKE 1 (1:44) 22-Charles Foxworth ran for -3 yards. Tackle by 54-Wallace Hall. SAFETY! (54-Wallace Hall) PENALTY - Holding (MKE 87-Lewis Hartley)
This was the summary
The 'Hold' penalty was declined in favor of the safety, but, (and I don't know if this is what you mean) in negating the hold penalty, the original play was run again, eg: 1st and 10 , which ever way its a bug.


Yes

Re: Safety Not Given

By Gustoon
1/20/2016 11:03 am
Ball on NYs 0 line, HB gets tackled for -1 yard, surely this is a safety? http://mfn32.myfootballnow.com/watch/1044#183905

Then no time outs called. All 3 left with 1:34 on the clocked, pinned on their 2 yd line, SURELY the worst coach in the world would have called a TO.
Last edited at 1/20/2016 11:09 am

Re: Safety Not Given

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
1/20/2016 11:07 am
Gustoon wrote:
Ball on NYs 0 line, HB gets tackled for -1 yard, surely this is a safety? http://mfn32.myfootballnow.com/watch/1044#183905


Forward progress was outside of the end zone.