Ragnulf-le-maudit wrote:
raymattison21 wrote:
Besides zone and drops any recent changes have had little effect in gameplay. I want to say reads are better but my 249 pound DT1 has 3 sacks and 8 pressures . Something is not right with pass protection and plays with longer snap to pass times. My qbs aren't fast but that rollout play is still pointless .
I don't think the reads are better. They continue to throw into multiple coverage with open WR available. My comp% is way down from last year, with same personnel.
And there is no pre-snap read.
I liked the concept of hot reads...they are not active /effective enough from 4.4 till now. It's kinda of a lost cause. But it kind of simulated a pre snap read.
But it got me thinking about pre snaps reads. We could have them, but as a balance we need to add the ability of defenders to choose to press or not. Its too random , and the addition of bump moderating route speed by acting like a cover skill has made reads rough. This is a few releases that have been plagued with poor reads.
Reads were never the best, but it's generally worse now. Still, I like to keep in mind how many poor reads or forced pass I see IRL every Sunday . But here completion % is way down for everyone except Puns team. He leads the league currently and is within nfl ranges. Glancing at his plan and roster....he's running a bunch of hitches with an elite wr and a good qb. But everyone else is low.
If pre snap reads added it would be kinda like custom progressions added but more in tune with the defensive call . Adding the ability to lock a defender on to a reciever combined with the ability to choose press for him would be a nice counter to custom progressions and pre snap reads.
It may work like this...... Pre snap, As a db chooses to press... an intelligent qb would read man and maybe put the offense in a better position to complete the slant/fly pass. Same if he'd read zone or cushion . ...then he could dump it off to the soft hole in coverage ...
This stuff would change reads but it would be more customized per team and opponent . Reads feel generalized . For all of 4.6 I constantly see wide open outside wrs dragging short over the middle and are completely ignored by my qbs. Just as much as they force passes to double coverage .