New Sticky Note

NOTICE: This league is using the BLEEDING EDGE game engine. For more information, click here.

The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

The draft is underway!

Click here to go to your war room, or visit the war room item in the draft menu.

League Forums

Main - General MFN Discussion

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By Wolfpack
9/28/2015 1:32 pm
There is also a some Free Agent Shopping going on….

A team will use cap space to pick up good free agent talent. That player then goes on the trade block for draft picks. They have to eat the bonus but most teams don't even come close to the cap limit anyway.

I guess that this isn't illegal but I think it goes against the spirt of the roster building system IMHO.

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By jgcruz
9/28/2015 1:40 pm
Wolfpack wrote:
There is also a some Free Agent Shopping going on….

A team will use cap space to pick up good free agent talent. That player then goes on the trade block for draft picks. They have to eat the bonus but most teams don't even come close to the cap limit anyway.

I guess that this isn't illegal but I think it goes against the spirt of the roster building system IMHO.


No team should be able to trade a fee agent at least until after the season starts during which he was signed - if at all (that is, until the end of the season during which he was signed).

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By Morbid
9/28/2015 2:00 pm
WarEagle wrote:
I don't see the need to limit position changes. I think a solution would be to have that player's position automatically change to their best position upon being released.



+1

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By Wolfpack
9/28/2015 2:58 pm
jgcruz wrote:
Wolfpack wrote:
There is also a some Free Agent Shopping going on….

A team will use cap space to pick up good free agent talent. That player then goes on the trade block for draft picks. They have to eat the bonus but most teams don't even come close to the cap limit anyway.

I guess that this isn't illegal but I think it goes against the spirt of the roster building system IMHO.


No team should be able to trade a fee agent at least until after the season starts during which he was signed - if at all (that is, until the end of the season during which he was signed).


Not how its working now, there's a nice little market of sign and trade going on.

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
9/28/2015 3:02 pm
jgcruz wrote:
No team should be able to trade a fee agent at least until after the season starts during which he was signed - if at all (that is, until the end of the season during which he was signed).


This is a restriction I will seriously consider.

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By parsh
9/28/2015 3:15 pm
Morbid wrote:
WarEagle wrote:
I don't see the need to limit position changes. I think a solution would be to have that player's position automatically change to their best position upon being released.



+1


Off the main topic .. But here is what is frustrating .. I just drafted a LT in Cst 9 rated 26/57 .. As a LG he is 28/60. I have never touch player weights so I am assuming I am at the default ratings. Shouldnt this player have been rated as a LG?

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By jsid
9/28/2015 3:28 pm
Wolfpack wrote:
There is also a some Free Agent Shopping going on….

A team will use cap space to pick up good free agent talent. That player then goes on the trade block for draft picks. They have to eat the bonus but most teams don't even come close to the cap limit anyway.

I guess that this isn't illegal but I think it goes against the spirt of the roster building system IMHO.


Admittedly I've done this, but it never occurred to me that people would be upset about it. Additionally, I've never signed a player I didn't think would help out my team if I kept them. Sometimes the circumstances change and I just try to make the most of it.

I also feel that even if I was trying to sign a guy just to trade him, it's more gamesmanship than something underhanded. Especially without cap rollover, why not use up your cap space on trade bait?

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By WarEagle
9/28/2015 3:30 pm
parsh wrote:
Morbid wrote:
WarEagle wrote:
I don't see the need to limit position changes. I think a solution would be to have that player's position automatically change to their best position upon being released.



+1


Off the main topic .. But here is what is frustrating .. I just drafted a LT in Cst 9 rated 26/57 .. As a LG he is 28/60. I have never touch player weights so I am assuming I am at the default ratings. Shouldnt this player have been rated as a LG?


He's rated based on whatever his assigned position is, and the weights you are using (custom or default). If you change the position you get a different rating (assuming the weights are different for the new position).
Last edited at 9/28/2015 3:32 pm

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By Webster922
9/28/2015 6:43 pm
I'm replying to jsid a post or two ago.

Completely agree. I sign players to help my team, but occasionally those players don't work out for me. The NFL doesn't force you to keep a player. You should be able to sign and trade as desired.

Even if someone is signing and trading, it does them as much harm as good because they are eating the bonus which is usually large for decent players. They are taking a chance on rookie draft picks that may not pan out as well.

Re: Strange Player Transactions

By Beercloud
9/28/2015 6:45 pm
Wolfpack wrote:
There is also a some Free Agent Shopping going on….

A team will use cap space to pick up good free agent talent. That player then goes on the trade block for draft picks. They have to eat the bonus but most teams don't even come close to the cap limit anyway.

I guess that this isn't illegal but I think it goes against the spirt of the roster building system IMHO.


I wonder if its possible to somehow have a loyality /greed factor to affect signing FA's.

When you release players, it affects other potential FA's attitudes towards considering your future offers. If you sign and release a very loyal player before his contract is up a hidden factor goes against you on signing other players. The more loyal a player is, the more he cares. A real greedy player could care less. And if you hang on to a player throughout his contract, the factor goes in your teams favor. If a player is with you throughout his career until his retirement it is a factor bonus.