NOTICE: This league is using the BLEEDING EDGE game engine. For more information, click here.

League Forums

Main - League Help Forum

Re: Passing Issues

By Firefly
7/13/2013 9:23 am
Pit-Clev my QB was as bad as usual, completing 50% of his passes with 2 ints, and Baltimore's was dismal, 9 of 31 with 2 ints.

What I think is happening now is that it's at the very least 2/3s (it actually feels more like closer to 100%, except for drops) up to the QB whether a pass is complete or not and QBs passes are all over the place, sometimes they miss by 20 yards and it looks bad, like a crazy roulette game. For aesthetic reasons, I think misses should always be close to the intended receiver.

But what I think really needs to happen is that the importance of coverage should go up compared to QB accuracy, even as the latter goes up, so that incompletes are, say, 50% about defensive competence, because right now, I'm not sure what the role of the defense is except to run around and hope the QB is inaccurate enough. Can't sack him, can't break up passes. Now, this defensive coverage "bonus" -or close coverage along with the ability to break up passes- should be much higher the farther downfield the receivers are, so that shorter passes are more easily completed.

Easier said than done, but that's what I think should happen.

Re: Passing Issues

By nero
7/13/2013 9:26 am
I was just to post another observation when I read this post.

In the test league tipped, batted, blocked ***** were a significant part of the game, that's all but vanished.

Re: Passing Issues

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
7/13/2013 10:13 am
I see that the changes I made didn't have the desired effect ... playing with some other changes now.

As for the tipped ***** and the defense, nothing has changed in that regard from the test league, so I'm not sure why knockdowns seem to be reduced. The only thing I can think of is something with the difference of player attributes here than we had in the test league.

Re: Passing Issues

By nero
7/13/2013 10:14 am
jdavidbakr wrote:
I see that the changes I made didn't have the desired effect ... playing with some other changes now.

As for the tipped ***** and the defense, nothing has changed in that regard from the test league, so I'm not sure why knockdowns seem to be reduced. The only thing I can think of is something with the difference of player attributes here than we had in the test league.


You mean a better talent base?

Re: Passing Issues

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
7/13/2013 10:19 am
nero wrote:
You mean a better talent base?


Yeah, and a greater disparity between the best and worst starters.
Last edited at 7/13/2013 10:19 am

Re: Passing Issues

By lordscarlet
7/13/2013 4:34 pm
11/40 for my QB

What data do you have for each pass attempt? Would it be possible to get a spray chart of some sort? Perhaps with a halo or something showing how many yards off an inaccurate throw was? If you do have that data and wouldn't mind making it available I'd be happy to try to put together what I am talking about.

Re: Passing Issues

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
7/13/2013 5:01 pm
lordscarlet wrote:
11/40 for my QB

What data do you have for each pass attempt? Would it be possible to get a spray chart of some sort? Perhaps with a halo or something showing how many yards off an inaccurate throw was? If you do have that data and wouldn't mind making it available I'd be happy to try to put together what I am talking about.


I started a rather lengthy and technical reply and then decided not to bore everyone with it, sent a PM instead.

Re: Passing Issues

By nero
7/13/2013 5:34 pm
jdavidbakr wrote:


I started a rather lengthy and technical reply and then decided not to bore everyone with it, sent a PM instead.


I'm interested in hearing it

Re: Passing Issues

By chinaski
7/18/2013 4:00 pm
ever since the changes were made, my team has been complete garbage. My QB is something like 30/130 the last three games. He was doing above decent before.

Re: Passing Issues

By jdavidbakr - Site Admin
7/18/2013 4:20 pm
chinaski wrote:
ever since the changes were made, my team has been complete garbage. My QB is something like 30/130 the last three games. He was doing above decent before.


Wow, he's going to be a good QB once he's fully developed but that accuracy bar is really low right now ... I wonder if you might be better off playing the rookie since your 2nd year QB is so raw.

To the end of the recent changes, there should be no case where the QB's accuracy is worse than it was before, in fact your QB should have gotten a pretty large boost from the changes. I'll have to watch your games and look at the logs and see if I can see something that's not behaving as expected, or if it's just a string of really bad luck.